• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Carlo’s Gourmet Pizzeria Restaurant & Caterers

At Carlo’s Gourmet Pizzeria Restaurant & Caterers, we invite you to experience Italian cuisine redefined. Nestled in Englishtown, NJ, our family-owned establishment is dedicated to serving authentic dishes made from the freshest ingredients. From our signature eggplant parmigiana to the indulgent shrimp marinara, each plate tells a story of tradition and craftsmanship. Our extensive menu caters to all diets, featuring ample vegetarian options ideal for gatherings or a casual night out. We pride ourselves on warm hospitality, an inviting atmosphere, and a commitment to quality, whether you're dining in or hosting an event. Enjoy the rich flavors of Italy right here at Carlo’s.

Carlo’s Gourmet Pizzeria Restaurant & Caterers: Reviews & Ratings

Cyrus Blades
Cyrus Blades

Food here is great, pizza, chicken parm were incredible. The reason Im leaving this review though is the staff, I dont think Ive met a more friendly and enthusiastic person than the guy behind the counter who took care of us, he bought ...

Brian Lindsay
Brian Lindsay

Great service. Very friendly and warm staff. Its a typical old fashioned pizzeria. They got some unique dishes of their own. Which sets them apart from others. Things Ive never seen, like this chicken parm looking monster sandwich that I ...

John Manfra
John Manfra

Awesome pizzeria. Very friendly very attentive. Food is fresh and hot. Prices are very affordable. Atmosphere is delightful. I go with my wife and my son probably once every two weeks for dinner. Great place highly recommend.

Robert Birmele
Robert Birmele

Top shelf pizza. Thin crust. Staff friendly and helpful. Clean.

Brittany Petrella
Brittany Petrella

We hosted my daughters birthday party here on 3825. The adorable party room blew us away. The room was set up when we walked in and the balloons arrived early and were already placed in the right spots. The room is adorable and the ...

Toni Ott
Toni Ott

Had my husbands and sons birthdays here!! I couldnt ask for a better time!! 28 guests and not one bad review. The food was hot, fresh and delish. And what made the party even better was Regina!! From ...

Yatin Pradhan
Yatin Pradhan

Been living in town for over 10yrs and finally found this spot. The pizza is awesome, good hold, nice crust, no flop, and sauce is nice n lil sweet. From plain slice to pepperoni to grandma to my fav of chix bacon ranch. The garlic knot ...

Mitch Friedlander
Mitch Friedlander

I lived in Marlboro 20 years ago, so when I was visiting the old neighborhood, I was pleasantly surprised to see Carlos still in business. I didnt see Maria, but the same great food, etc... some traditions should never change!! ...

Location

Welcome to Carlo’s Gourmet Pizzeria Restaurant & Caterers, a delightful sanctuary for Italian cuisine located at 326 US Hwy 9 in Englishtown, NJ. This charming eatery offers a sumptuous array of pizzas and Italian dishes that promise an unforgettable dining experience. Whether you're stopping by for a casual lunch or hosting a grand celebration, Carlo's caters to all your culinary cravings.

The atmosphere here strikes a perfect balance between casual comfort and vibrant energy. With outdoor seating, it’s an ideal spot for families and friends to gather, while kids are sure to enjoy the warm, welcoming environment. Plus, the availability of free Wi-Fi and large television screens makes it a great place for groups to unwind or catch up on a game.

  • Diverse Menu: From classic pies to gluten-free offerings, Carlo's has something for everyone. Signature dishes include the Hot Antipasto—a medley of flavors featuring clams oreganata and stuffed mushrooms—an ideal starter that sets the stage for a memorable meal.
  • Vegetarian Choices: With multiple vegetarian options on the menu, Carlo’s ensures that everyone can find a satisfying dish without sacrificing flavor.
  • Convenience: Reservations are accepted, and with both delivery and takeout options, enjoying gourmet pizza has never been easier. For those on the go, Apple Pay and credit cards are readily accepted.

The standout feature of Carlo’s is their dedication to quality. Their attention to detail is evident in every bite. For example, the gluten-free offerings do not compromise taste, with dishes like gluten-free chicken tenders and baked clams oreganata receiving rave reviews. It’s clear that Carlo’s commitment extends beyond just traditional recipes; they strive to create inclusive options that cater to every palate.

In summary, Carlo’s Gourmet Pizzeria Restaurant & Caterers is not just another pizza place. It represents a harmonious blend of fine dining and friendly service, making it a perfect spot for everyone—from families to casual diners looking for a delicious meal. As I savored each dish during my visit, I felt not just nourished but completely satisfied, eager to return and explore more of their delectable menu. It’s an establishment that truly embodies the essence of Italian hospitality, and I wholeheartedly recommend stopping by to indulge in their culinary delights!